On the day before Easter, when Homer attempts to start work in the Power Plant, he is told to go to Mr. Burns' mansion. After Homer arrived at Mr. Burns' mansion, Mr. Burns wants Homer to pretend to be the Easter bunny. But before he does so, Mr. Burns gets Homer to go all the back side of Mr. Burns' mansion in order to go inside the mansion to get the Easter basket with 20 chocolate eggs. Soon, Mr. Burns gives the bunny ears for Homer to wear, until Homer started to hide all the eggs at the Evergreen Terrace sign, until something happened to the chocolate eggs afterwards. When Mr. Burns found out that Homer hid every chocolate eggs at the Evergreen Terrace sign, Homer actually messed up (when he was meant to hide the chocolate eggs into random places). So when Homer drive back to the Evergreen Terrace, he and Mr. Burns found out that someone stole 20 chocolate eggs. So they decided to follow the skidmarks to find a man who stole 20 chocolate eggs to get them back before the man sells them to his friend. Once after Homer and Mr. Burns finally found 20 chocolate eggs, Homer decides to try again. But this time, Homer hides the chocolate eggs into different locations at once, except that he hid one chocolate egg inside the dumpster at the Krusty Burger along the way, so much to Mr. Burns' dismay. After Mr. Burns finds out that one chocolate egg is inside the dumpster, he gets Homer to find the garbage truck to destroy it before it collects garbage from the Krusty Burger's dumpster, so Homer can save the chocolate egg out from the dumpster, until he decides to hide it behind Ned Flanders' house. Afterwards, Homer and Mr. Burns decides to go to the Kwik-E-Mart to buy more chocolate eggs before Homer can hide more chocolate eggs into the inside places, but apparently someone already stole the chocolate eggs shipment that Apu was supposed to sell in the Kwik-E-Mart. So Homer and Mr. Burns decide to look for Snake who might be behind all this. Along the way, Homer has to distract Snake while Mr. Burns finds the chocolate eggs shipment that were sitting inside Snake's trunk, until Mr. Burns and Homer returns the chocolate eggs shipment to Apu, before Homer can finally buy the chocolate eggs. Will Snake be able to believe that he did steal the chocolate eggs shipment? And will Homer be able to find a way how to get Snake to jail after what Snake did?