Skyrim

Recent updates: nested commenting, sticky posts, latest versions, drag n dropping and bug fixes

  • Comment
Things have been flying by a bit recently and we’ve been boshing out so many small fixes, tweaks and features left right and centre I’m almost struggling to keep up. So here’s a run-down of some of the recent changes we’ve implemented on the sites and in NMM.


Nested commenting

I’ve been wanting to get this functionality implemented on the sites for a long while now but there was no point getting it done until we upgraded the forums (which was done within the last fortnight). Nested commenting allows users to reply to comments made on the sites and have those comments and replies grouped together for easy viewing.

Before nested commenting everyone’s comments were shown in a linear progression, one above the other, ordered by the date and time the comment was posted. It meant if you asked a question on a file page at 10am and the author (or anyone) couldn’t answer that question until 5pm, there could have been any number of comments (sometimes even hundreds) made on the file page in between the time you posted and the time a reply could be posted. That made finding the answer to your question very hard. Now, you can reply to the comments people make, and because they’re grouped together you’ll easily be able to see if anyone has replied to the comments you’ve made.

We’ve only provided one level of replying to comments. So comments only get nested (and indented) once. You can’t reply to a reply and have that reply indented further. Hopefully that makes sense. So you can’t have these crazy nested reply chains like you can on a site like reddit. It gets a bit messy!


Author’s sticky post

Something I know authors need help with is increasing awareness to their users about various things from incompatibilities, common issues, install instructions and what not. The inherent problem with the internet is there’s a percentage of users who seem to suffer from a form of attention deficit disorder and can’t spend the time reading the file description, readmes, FAQs and author warnings in big glaring multi-coloured fonts before they try to install a mod. If they can’t get it to work they then go to the comments section, completely by-passing everything the author has written on the topic in various locations and start asking for help. That’s REALLY frustrating if you’re a mod author. Unfortunately there’s not much you or we can do about that. If someone is really that dumb that they don’t read anything before asking for help then no amount of warnings, pop-up notifications and forced reading will solve the issue (much like our terms of service agreement boxes, or the big glaring boxes in the image share telling people not to upload nude images).

However, we’ll try to help with this issue in whatever way we can, and to that end we’ve introduced a “sticky post” system that allows file authors to sticky a single post in their comment thread. The post goes to the top of the comment section, where it is “stuck” there on every comment page, with a red border and a notification that it’s a sticky post from the author.

As an author this has some practical uses. Are you aware there’s a bug in your latest version that you’re working hard to fix? Maybe some major incompatibilities? People keep on bringing up the same issues that aren’t actually issues with your mod? Sticky a post to the top of your comments to let users know they don’t need to spam your comment section with bug reports about it. I’m sure you’ll still get bug reports from those previously mentioned users who DO NOT READ before they act (RAGE!) but hopefully you’ll be able to catch a few more people with such a notification that should help to reduce the load.

Something I’ve noticed from my time using the PC Gamer website, where they have nested commenting, is that the comment at the top of an article can often be used by people to talk about things completely unrelated to the original post. While we haven’t coded in a system to “lock” your sticky post (so people can’t reply to it with unrelated stuff) if it becomes obvious that it’s needed, we’ll do it. I’ll await mod author feedback for that one.


Latest version check box

The versioning system on the Nexus is far from complex, uniform or standardised. We let you guys version your mods however you like. Unfortunately sometimes this can lead to inconsistencies, especially with NMM where the latest version column checks the file version the user has installed against the file version shown on the file page (via the “edit attributes” page), not the file versions of your individually uploaded files. So if your file page says the latest version is v1.2 and your uploaded files have a file that’s v1.3, your latest file version is still v1.2.

While we want to visit the versioning system in more detail later, especially in regards to NMM, right now we’ve just added a quick and easy system for you to update your latest versions. We’ve added a checkbox when uploading your files that asks you if this is the latest version of your file. If you tick the box the latest file version information for your file will be updated with the content of the “file version” text field you’ve used in the upload form. Saves you going back and editing your attributes with your new version.


NMM drag n drop
Version 0.43.1 of NMM has added a small but useful feature for those people who still download their mods manually from the sites. You can now drag and drop files from your desktop into NMM directly, avoiding having to use the “add from file” functionality.

Right now this feature only works while in category mode. We’re working on updating the non-category view to use the same controller as the category view so it can make use of all the cool features the category view has, like being able to sort the columns, and the drag and drop functionality.


NMM bug fixes

Along with this feature update the latest version of NMM also contains some bug fixes. Here’s the change log:

*InstallLog didn't properly check for already present random mod keys (this will prevent the "An item with the same key has already been added" crash).
*Mod autoupdate check removing category info from mods, causing missing mods from categories.
*Uac check crashing with illegal folder paths.
*Scripted mod install failing when the installer tried to show a message to the user (throwing a Security exception).
*ProgressDialog bug causing mod update checks to fail.
*Illegal folder paths crashing the game scan process.
*The "move to category" ContextMenu didn't properly sort alphabetically.
*Prevents the user from settings Mods or Install Info folders equal to: HD root, game root, installed mods folder.


What we’re now working on

Moving on we’ve got lots of new features in the pipeline for both the sites and NMM.

Right now I’m working on some updates to the site’s design, which I’m sure will fill a lot of you with fear and dread. It’s not going to be a full redesign of the sites like we had last year at all. You’ll still recognise the sites, I promise. If you’re a mod author you can see my mock up for the file page redesign in the private mod author forums that I’ve appropriately titled “fixing things that aren’t broken”. I hope to do the changes progressively. So I’ll be changing the header about a bit to better manage the space. We’ll do that first. Then we might update the file pages. Then the category view. Then the site index. I don’t have plans for any other pages just yet.

The clever site coders are working on the bandwidth throttling system based on ads and endorsements that I brought up in my last blog post. They’re also working on a new feature for mod authors that’s going to let them pick and crop the images they want to use for their hot files and “feature image” on the new file page.

Our hot file system is quite unforgiving when it comes to picking and cropping the images it wants to use, and how it crops them, so we want a system where you can pick the image the site will use as it’s hot file image (if your file becomes a hot file) and also pick which area of the image gets cropped so it advertises your mod in its best light. This will be handy not just for people with popular mods because I also plan to use hot file images in the new category design, where we’re going to have a “featured” mod; a mod that is randomly picked from the category that will be advertised in the category for a set amount of time, and then sent to the back of the pile before it can be shown again as a feature mod. A form of banner advertising and rotation for mods, if you will.

On the NMM front we’re working on the aforementioned update to the non-category view, more bug fixing, better readme management and our initial work into creating a really easy to use mod packager for authors who want to ensure their mods work with NMM and, drum-roll, better scripting support as a part of it. We want to make it so that mod authors who don’t know how to script and don’t want to learn can still make some pretty neat installers that give their users more options when installing.

We’re aware there’s still some niggling issues with the forum upgrade for those people who use the forums. We’re aware of them (especially the VERY annoying bug that is causing edited posts to come up in garbled HTML at random), but some things are taking a higher priority right now. Word of advice that applies at any time; always copy and paste your long posts into notepad before posting a response.

140 comments

Comments locked

A moderator has closed this comment topic for the time being
  1. chromechris
    chromechris
    • member
    • 7 kudos
    Sorry to be a thorn in your side.

    Though the feature named hide and request moderation on a comment, should be perhaps renamed simply hide, as in my experiance it doesnt actually call a moderator.

    A bug no doubt?
  2. Loshirai14
    Loshirai14
    • premium
    • 508 kudos
    Bug Report:
    - Fast Reply on the forum seems to be broken
  3. sevencardz
    sevencardz
    • premium
    • 306 kudos
    Quoting Talic29 -

    "A search feature for the comments on each mod without having to go into the actual forum post would be amazing. I already have a million tabs open when I'm on here, so opening multiple comment tabs as well just so I can do a keyword search tends to get quite cluttered.

    Sticky comments are win though."

    I completely agree with all of this and I didn't even know you could go to the forum page itself and search that - WOW, please implement this feature if possible.
  4. Dark0ne
    Dark0ne
    • Site Owner
    • 2,887 kudos
    Nested comments now display in the correct order, you can lock sticky posts from replies, mod author replies will have the coloured border the same as mod author posts and replies of posts will be more obvious in forum view with links to the main comment and other replies to the same comment.
    1. Loshirai14
      Loshirai14
      • premium
      • 508 kudos
      yay!!
    2. sydney666
      sydney666
      • premium
      • 603 kudos
      No offence intended here Dark0ne but I am really disliking nested comments after having spent a lot of time with them now in my mod comments.

      I am getting completely lost trying to track comments now. Now with the "correct" comment order, you have to scroll all the way down to read all the comments and all the way up to reply to them. A reply button near the last comment will help here.

      I also have no easy way of finding out where the comments were updated and quite possibly they could occur many pages back. I certainly don't want email spam (like the PM function) to track them, but maybe that's the only viable solution to this issue. Maybe an "unread comments" button at the top of the comments page, which automatically helps the author of the mod find the latest post - almost like an email function that tells you how many unread emails you have.

      In all honesty, a quoting function has worked for decades and while nested seems like a good idea, it's very messy for mod authors to track. I know I am not the only one who finds it a pain, but I am sure many others like it too - so a nice balance would be key here.

      Cheers,

      Tony
    3. sevencardz
      sevencardz
      • premium
      • 306 kudos
      I agree, I think there should be a global expiration date on all posts (per mod and set by the mod author or moderator). That way it would not be possible to reply to a post from say 2 weeks ago .. nobody is going to go 5+ pages back to look at it anyway. At that point, either repeat the topic in the original post, quote the author of that post or ... this may be wishful thinking ... provide a way to link directly to a previous post so that I can click and see the original post to which the new post is replying.
  5. WaxEKZ
    WaxEKZ
    • member
    • 0 kudos
    Same here. New version crashes/freezes when deleting mods.
  6. RussianPlant
    RussianPlant
    • member
    • 0 kudos
    Newest version of NMM crashes when I delete a mod.
  7. steve40
    steve40
    • premium
    • 1,149 kudos
    @Steve: How is the sitebot supposed to know which posts are  replies to a hidden post and not stand alone posts in the same thread?  This would work for nested comments, And with a lot more work, possibly those that quote it. But not so good for those that do neither but possibly refer to that hidden post or have multiple quotes.
     
    It would be less work for me as I do try to hide comments that refer to hidden comments - depending on the comments.

     
    bben46, I'm refering to the removal of nested comments in a hidden post of course. It would be helpful if this could be done automatically (this is the "nested commenting" feedback thread, right?  .
  8. EvilDeadAsh34
    EvilDeadAsh34
    • premium
    • 210 kudos
    Oh my god! I can't delete my own comments anymore! Nooooooooooooo!!! Please re-consider adding this back because it was incredibly useful. It helped keep the comments sections of my mods more tidy. Especially since the nested comments (while useful) are making such a mess of things.

    Alas, i'm sure this is gone for good (a bug, really??? come on...).
  9. bben46
    bben46
    • premium
    • 781 kudos
    In response to post #7490558.
     

    what if it's my own comment?
    what reason will i write?
    will i write "because i want to delete my own comment"
    would you delete it?

    Having seen the kind of abuse this opens up on other sites I agree with Dark0ne's decision. And yes, if I see a you have a reason for wanting to remove your own comment, I will do it - as I have in the past. 
    1. Loshirai14
      Loshirai14
      • premium
      • 508 kudos
      there's no feature to report our own comments right?
      it's not even possible unless you decide to add that feature..
      the only thing we could do now is Edit our comment then change it to:
      ***Comment Deleted***..
    2. Dark0ne
      Dark0ne
      • Site Owner
      • 2,887 kudos
      Yes, you can report your own comments. Very easily.
    3. Loshirai14
      Loshirai14
      • premium
      • 508 kudos
      oh... so that's what 'report' does..
      i never would have guessed it >_<

      i thought it was used to report the user and not the post.
      silly me
  10. Dark0ne
    Dark0ne
    • Site Owner
    • 2,887 kudos
    I'll also add that even if you believe that you are a customer on this site my philosophy is most definitely "the customer is NOT always right".